🎧
Romance
The Fault in Our Stars
0 reviews
View →
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Verdict first, because this book sorts listeners fast: if a laugh-out-loud romantic comedy between two serial killers who only murder worse murderers sounds like your exact brand of wrong, Butcher & Blackbird is one of the most purely entertaining audio productions we have covered this year. If that sentence made you wince, trust the wince, this one is not for you, and no review will change that. Now, for the people still here: let us talk about why the audiobook specifically became a BookTok legend.
Sloane and Rowan meet over the same target, two vigilante killers discovering, mid-hunt, that the other exists. Instead of killing each other, they invent a game: once a year, a chosen monster, first to the kill wins, loser buys dinner. What follows is a years-long, slow-burn, friends-to-lovers arc conducted across crime scenes, with banter sharp enough to draw blood and gore played, somehow, for genuine comedy. Weaver calls it a dark rom-com and means both halves: the romance is sincere and scorching, and the dark is DARK, accidental cannibalism is a real plot point, and the book's own trigger-warning page is famous for being simultaneously necessary and hilarious.
Here is the production detail that matters: Joe Arden and Lucy Rivers recorded this together, in actual conversation, not spliced solo sessions, and the difference is audible in every exchange. Rivers gives Sloane strength with a vulnerable seam; Arden's Rowan, complete with a swoon-engineered Irish accent, is the performance the fandom will not stop talking about, and on the evidence, fairly. The chemistry is not implied; it is recorded. Among romance duets we have reviewed, only the best full-cast productions come close to this level of live-wire interplay.
You need realism, restraint, or a body count in single digits. Gore, explicit content, and profanity are constant, this is emphatically 18+, and the tonal whiplash between slapstick and slaughter is the point, not a flaw. Check the trigger warnings; they are not decorative.
Well narrated? The duet recording is the gold standard for romance chemistry in audio. Deranged, hilarious, weirdly sweet, and completely committed to its bit. The right listener will inhale the whole trilogy.
Verity for dark-romance-adjacent thrills with a very different temperature, or The Housemaid if you want your twisted domestic fun with less arterial spray.
Joe Arden and Lucy Rivers narrate the Blue Nose Publishing edition together in duet style, recorded in the same session, trading dialogue live rather than in separate solo takes. The resulting chemistry is the production's signature.
Genuinely dark: graphic violence, gore played for comedy, and explicit sexual content throughout. It is 18+ without qualification, and the author's own trigger-warning list is extensive. The comedy does not soften the content; it coexists with it.
Yes, it opens the Ruinous Love Trilogy, with each book following a different couple in the same deranged universe. This is the entry point and the fan favorite.
About 8 hours 43 minutes, short, fast, and engineered for a weekend binge.
You can hear Butcher & Blackbird free with an Audible trial, new members get their first title included. (Affiliate link, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.)
No approved reviews yet. Be the first to write one.
