🎧
History
Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind
4 reviews
View →
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Walter Isaacson had two years of unprecedented access to Elon Musk, his meetings, his factories, his family, his adversaries. Jeremy Bobb had twenty hours to bring that access to your ears. The combination makes for a technically exceptional production of a subject who divides opinion like almost no living public figure, and reviewing the audiobook honestly means reviewing both, the recording and the question of whether you want to spend twenty hours inside a portrait this intimate of this particular man.
More texture than any previous Musk account, and more of it uncomfortable. The childhood in Pretoria, the bullying, the father who occupies an entire chapter's worth of psychological complexity. The PayPal founding, narrated with more nuance about who contributed what than tech myth usually allows. The Tesla and SpaceX chapters, which alternate between genuinely inspiring scenes of mission-driven manufacturing and scenes of casual cruelty to employees that Isaacson neither condemns nor excuses. The Twitter acquisition, which Isaacson had live access to. The book's central question, are the demons that drive Musk the same things that make him capable of what he has accomplished, is asked honestly and left genuinely open.
We want to be direct about something reviewers often sidestep: Bobb's performance of this particular audiobook has divided listeners. His delivery is precise, technically proficient, and emotionally neutral, qualities that suit Isaacson's measured, analytical prose but that several listeners describe as flat for a subject this kinetic. For the long policy and manufacturing chapters, the neutrality is an asset; for the interpersonal confrontation scenes, you occasionally wish for more controlled electricity. This is not a performance failure, it is a deliberate tonal choice, and the book is long enough that a more dramatic narrator would become exhausting. But it is worth knowing before you spend twenty hours with him.
Inevitable, since Isaacson wrote both. The Steve Jobs book has a cleaner dramatic arc, a founding, an exile, a return, a death. The Musk book has a subject who is still mid-story, which makes it feel structurally less resolved. In audio, Dylan Baker's reading of Steve Jobs is the warmer performance; Bobb's Musk is technically superior. Both are worth your time, in different ways, for different purposes.
Well narrated? Proficiently, with a caveat about tonal flatness on high-drama scenes. The most complete portrait of the most divisive builder alive; twenty hours well spent if you want to understand the person behind the headlines, rather than confirm what you already believe about him.
Shoe Dog for a warmer founder memoir, or Zero to One for Musk's collaborator Peter Thiel's philosophy on building companies that change the world.
Yes, particularly if you want a ground-level account of how his companies actually operate, rather than mythology. The Twitter acquisition chapters alone are worth the credit for anyone interested in how major decisions get made at speed. The portrait is sympathetic to Musk in some ways and damning in others.
Jeremy Bobb narrates the unabridged Simon & Schuster Audio edition. His delivery is precise and professional; some listeners find it flat for material this dramatic, which is worth knowing at twenty hours.
20 hours and 38 minutes, one of the longer biographies we cover. At 1.25x it compresses to about sixteen hours, which most listeners find the right speed for the denser manufacturing and finance chapters.
More balanced than many critics suggested at publication. Isaacson shows Musk's genuine achievements and his cruelty to employees with equal vividness, and he explicitly avoids the verdict on whether the tradeoffs are acceptable, leaving that to the reader.
You can hear Elon Musk free with an Audible trial. (Affiliate link, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.)
No approved reviews yet. Be the first to write one.
